Kanaky New Caledonia: Leadership Changes, But What Else?

By Antonia Bhagwan

“Mom, what is politics for? You keep going to all these meetings, but I do not feel like anything changes.

For Ikée Emiliana Toutikian-Blondeel, a municipal councillor in Mont-Dore, Kanaky New Caledonia, the question came from her 14-year-old son. She did not have an answer ready.

It is also a question she hears from the young people in her community.

In Kanaky New Caledonia, the recent provincial election produced a new institutional configuration in a territory still grappling with the consequences of the 2024 uprising.

The election, which took place on 28 June 2026, saw Pro-French forces retain a significant influence. What also remained were questions of representation, the disputed 2021 Referendum, and the future of the decolonisation process.

For Kanak communities, the outcome is yet another stage in their long-standing political struggle. “There is a desire to move forward, but trust still needs to be rebuilt,” says Ikée Emiliana Toutikian-Blondeel.

“Elections provide representation and a framework for political work, but on their own, they are not enough to erase what we have been through since 2024.”

The question, then, is not simply who won the elections. It is what comes after it.

An election in a contested framework

The concerns surrounding the new political configuration begin with the conditions under which the elections took place.

Viro Xulue, a Human Rights and Indigenous Law Officer, says the provincial election occurred within a “profoundly compromised” institutional context.

At the centre of the debate is the Special Electoral Roll for the Provincial Assembly and Congress. Frozen since a 2007 constitutional reform, excludes approximately 17 per cent of people registered on the general electoral roll.

The growing gap, he says, raises questions about the legitimacy of the election result itself.

The United Nations (UN) Special Committee on Decolonization, or C-24, has also raised concerns about divergent interpretations of the restricted electorate and called for future consultations to comply with the “spirit and letter” of the Nouméa Accord.

Although the Accord’s original 20-year timeframe has elapsed, its institutional arrangements remain in force, leaving questions over Kanaky’s political future and the framework for its ongoing decolonisation unresolved.

For Xulue, the election has changed the internal balance of power, but does not alter the territory’s international legal status.

Kanaky New Caledonia remains on the UN list of Non-Self-Governing Territories. As the administering power, France continues to carry international responsibilities for the territory’s political development and self-government.

The question is not simply whether Kanak representatives can participate within the institutions that exist, but whether those institutions can advance the process of decolonisation at all.
Stability beyond the ballot box

In Mont-Dore, Kanaky New Caledonia, the consequences of political instability are felt beyond election results and institutional debate.

Toutikian-Blondeel, who is also a member of Dynamique Unitaire Sud (DUS), under the Front de Libération Nationale Kanak et Socialiste (FLNKS), says residents continue to raise issues including security, social housing, academic support in tribes and restrictions affecting residents of Saint-Louis.

“Reaching peace happens first in that daily life,” she says.

“Institutions have a responsibility that goes beyond their basic operation: to explain their choices, listen to disagreements, and provide answers.”

She describes a local political environment where security has become a dominant concern, particularly following the 2024 unrest.

The 2024 unrest erupted following proposed French constitutional reforms to expand the electorate in provincial elections, triggering widespread protests, roadblocks and violent clashes across Greater Nouméa, including Mont-Dore.

While she understands where the root of this anxiety comes from, “security alone is enough to bring peace to a municipality,” she says.

“That is why I advocate for a different approach on my end: more dialogue, more support, and more prevention.”
This presents a challenge for political authorities to finally address the social and historical conditions that contributed to the 2024 unrest, or if the focus will remain on security and institutional control.

The Pacific Peoples’ Mission to Kanaky New Caledonia (2025), which examined the situation following the unrest, found that political mistrust, widening socio-economic inequalities and limited opportunities for Kanak youth continue to undermine social stability. The Mission also highlighted the incomplete reconciliation process and the exclusion of Kanak communities from recovery planning.

For Roselyne Makalu, a community activist and media specialist, those questions cannot be separated from the territory’s economic crisis.

She says living conditions for already vulnerable populations have deteriorated considerably since the uprising.
The economic downturn, including the slowdown or shutdown of nickel processing plants such as Koniambo, has translated into job losses and increasing pressure on households.

Families have struggled with transportation, school costs, healthcare, housing and employment. Some have returned from urban areas to their native villages, while others have moved into informal settlements.

However, Makalu says the crisis cannot be understood entirely as an economic or social one.

“The political question of decolonisation conditions the entirety of the debate.”

A generation growing up through crisis

The political crisis has entered family life, and there are fears that this is becoming a norm for Kanaks.

Toutikian-Blondeel says young people are searching for their place in the political process that has shaped much of their lives.

“Political instability always finds its way into homes,” she says, pointing to lost employment, reduced incomes and disrupted schooling.

Her concerns are also shaped by conversations with her own children.

Her 14-year-old son, Atéè, has also questioned what politics means when the changes being debated by adults are not always visible in the lives of young people.

Toutikian-Blondeel says young people need to feel recognised “in school, in institutions, and in their own country.”

“A child should be able to learn without leaving who they are at the classroom door,” she says.

Makalu similarly describes the continuing effects of the crisis on young people and families, particularly as communities attempt to process the trauma of 2024.

She says the uprising reopened memories of the 1984–1988 period of civil conflict.

Women in greater Nouméa mobilised around roadblocks, concerned for young people facing arrest or violence, while also creating spaces for dialogue, cultural activities and intergenerational transmission.

For both women, the future cannot be separated from the work of healing from past and present trauma.

Differing definitions of community security

The continuing presence of French security forces adds another layer to the question of political participation.

Toutikian-Blondeel acknowledges that security can reassure some residents, but says its meaning is very different for others.

“In Mont-Dore, this presence has increased enormously since 2024, and I see its effect even in how our youth talk about it among themselves,” she says.

The events of the civil unrest have led to deep trauma in communities, especially for Kanak youth, where the pain sometimes evolves into “anger” and “hatred” toward law enforcement.

“In a country marked by colonisation, this difference in perception must be heard, not dismissed.”

She argues that it is important to acknowledge the suffering experienced across different communities without erasing colonial history or the inequalities that already existed before 2024, adding that people must be able to question security measures while still demanding protection for people and property.

“Freely participating in dialogue assumes being able to express disagreement without fear of being immediately reduced to a threat,” she says. “Pro-independence voices must have a full place in democratic and peaceful debate.”

Makalu raises similar concerns about the security environment and the media landscape.

She says French security forces have been significantly reinforced since the referendum period. Similarly, the media environment is dominated by pro-France outlets, with Radio Djiido remaining the only pro-independence media outlet.

Social media has turned into a key space where people inform themselves and exchange political views, but Makulu says it is also marked by racism and hostility.

Toutikian-Blondeel argues that the media therefore has a responsibility not only to show confrontation, but to provide context and represent the everyday lives of communities.

“When a young person or a tribe only appears through images of confrontation, their daily life is misunderstood,” she says.

The need for meaningful dialogue

The question of what happens next ultimately extends beyond the provincial assembly.

Xulue points to the continuing role of the UN decolonisation system, including the C-24, as a mechanism for maintaining international attention on Kanaky New Caledonia.

He identifies several possible pathways, including UN-facilitated mediation, closer monitoring through UN human rights mechanisms and greater regional participation.

The FLNKS and Kanak customary institutions have called for UN-facilitated mediation, while the Melanesian Spearhead Group (MSG) and Pacific Islands Forum (PIF) have already brought the issue into regional and international forums. According to Xulue, Pacific involvement is particularly important because it prevents the question from being treated simply as a domestic French political matter.

The MSG has maintained coordinated diplomatic engagement, while PIF has also undertaken regional engagement following the 2024 crisis.

At the community level, Toutikian-Blondeel also sees dialogue as something that must extend beyond political leaders.

“Dialogue must leave real room for disagreement,” she says. “You cannot ask people to come talk while expecting only their approval.”

That process also needs an intergenerational dimension, as Toutikian-Blondeel points to initiatives connecting women across generations.

She argues that women must have meaningful participation in decision-making, supported by practical measures such as transport, childcare, scheduling and language accessibility.

“As a Kanak woman, mother, and elected official, I want to contribute to this work,” she says.

She then returns to her son’s question: “What is it for?”

“I want my sons to grow up at home with their identity respected, real prospects, and a full, complete place in the future of Kanaky.”

For more information, contact: Jennis Naidu | Media & Communications Manager | Pacific Network on Globalisation (PANG) | Email: communications@pang.org.fj